| Year | Name | Position | College |
|---|---|---|---|
1919 |
Walter "Red" Mahan |
Guard |
West Virginia |
1928 |
John Cox |
Center |
Colgate |
1929 |
John Cox |
Center |
Colgate |
1932 |
Robert Smith |
Guard |
Colgate |
1943 |
Casmir Myslinski |
Center |
Army |
1954 |
Calvin Jones |
Tackle |
Iowa |
1955 |
Calvin Jones |
Tackle |
Iowa |
1956 |
Frank "Shag" Gilliam |
End |
Iowa |
1966 |
Harry Wilson |
Halfback |
Nebraska |
